Back to Blog

Comparative Analysis of Making Tax Digital Software Options

Posted on 16 May 2025

Overview

The article presents a comparative analysis of Making Tax Digital (MTD) software options, underscoring their critical role for UK accountants in navigating new tax regulations.

In today’s rapidly evolving landscape, accountants face significant challenges in compliance and efficiency. Choosing the right MTD software, such as Glasscubes, renowned for its user-friendly features and automation capabilities, can dramatically improve operational efficiency and client satisfaction.

User feedback and statistics reveal substantial time savings, reinforcing the platform’s effectiveness. As the accounting industry adapts to these changes, embracing such innovative solutions is not just beneficial—it’s essential for staying competitive.

Act now to enhance your practise with the right tools.

Key Highlights:

  • Making Tax Digital (MTD) requires UK businesses to maintain digital records and submit tax returns electronically, necessitating a shift in accounting practices.
  • Accountants must adopt MTD-compliant technology to avoid penalties and improve operational efficiency, with 23% of agent filings completed using TaxCalc last year.
  • Approximately 11.5 million individuals file returns, highlighting the importance of accountants mastering MTD regulations to assist clients effectively.
  • Many small business owners are concerned about understanding MTD legislation and managing the additional workload, stressing the need for education on MTD.
  • Critiques of HMRC’s website emphasize the importance of efficient MTD-compliant software, such as Glasscubes, which streamlines communication and reduces response times.
  • Key features for evaluating MTD software include adherence to HMRC requirements, user-friendly interfaces, integration capabilities, automation, real-time reporting, and security compliance.
  • Glasscubes stands out among MTD software options due to its automated features, real-time reporting, and improved customer engagement, saving users significant time.
  • When choosing MTD software, accountants should consider firm size, customer volume, budget constraints, future scalability, and availability of training and support.
  • Successful implementation of MTD software can lead to improved accuracy in tax reporting and enhanced client satisfaction, as demonstrated by positive user feedback.

Introduction

The landscape of accounting is undergoing a seismic shift with the introduction of Making Tax Digital (MTD) in the UK, compelling accountants to rethink their traditional practices. This digital transformation mandates businesses to keep electronic records and submit tax returns online, ushering in a new era of compliance and efficiency.

As accountants navigate this complex terrain, the adoption of MTD-compliant software becomes paramount—not just to avoid penalties but to enhance client service and operational workflows. With millions of individuals affected by this change, the pressure mounts for accounting professionals to stay informed and equipped.

This article delves into the implications of MTD for accountants, the critical features to consider when selecting software, and a comparative analysis of leading solutions that promise to streamline the transition while bolstering client satisfaction.

Understanding Making Tax Digital: Implications for Accountants

Making Tax Digital (MTD) represents a transformative shift in the UK tax framework, mandating businesses to maintain digital records and submit tax returns electronically. This transition compels financial professionals to reassess their workflows, emphasising the importance of digital compliance. The implications are significant: professionals must equip their practises with MTD-compliant technology to avoid penalties and enhance operational efficiency. Notably, statistics reveal that 23% of agent third-party filings were completed using TaxCalc in the last tax year, underscoring the increasing reliance on specialised software to meet MTD requirements. Furthermore, with approximately 11.5 million individuals filing returns, mastering the intricacies of MTD is crucial for professionals aiming to assist their clients effectively.

As MTD becomes fully operational, those who adapt to these changes are poised to gain a competitive edge. However, many financial professionals acknowledge the necessity of deepening their understanding of MTD regulations to better support their clients. A recent study indicates that a substantial number of small business owners express concerns regarding their comprehension of MTD legislation and the management of the additional workload it entails. This situation emphasises the urgency for accountants to educate themselves and their clients about MTD, facilitating a smoother transition and mitigating the risk of non-compliance penalties. Additionally, the challenges associated with MTD compliance are exacerbated by critiques of HMRC’s website, which has been described as slow and cumbersome for professional use, particularly for fee-paying customers. This reality further underscores the importance of adopting efficient MTD-compliant software that can streamline communication and enhance customer service. Glasscubes stands out in this regard, offering automated reminders and real-time visibility that significantly reduce response times and improve customer interactions. By consolidating all correspondence within each audit request, Glasscubes eradicates the inefficiencies of traditional email communication, ensuring that no information is lost or duplicated. This effectively addresses the prevalent issues of lost information and duplicated requests that financial professionals encounter when relying on email.

In conclusion, the impact of MTD on accounting practises is profound, fostering greater accuracy in tax reporting and establishing more efficient communication channels between financial experts and HMRC. By adopting MTD-compliant solutions such as Glasscubes, professionals can not only enhance their operational workflows but also elevate client satisfaction, positioning themselves advantageously in an increasingly digital landscape.

Accountants Adapting to Making Tax Digital

Criteria for Evaluating MTD Software: Key Features and Considerations

When assessing MTD applications, accountants should prioritise several essential features:

  • Adherence to HMRC Requirements: The application must comply with HMRC’s MTD regulations, ensuring that all submissions are precise and punctual. This compliance is crucial, as businesses with a taxable turnover below £85,000 are not required to comply with MTD for VAT rules, while MTD for Income Tax will impact approximately 780,000 higher-income sole traders starting April 6, 2026.

  • User-Friendly Interface: A straightforward interface minimises the learning curve, facilitating quicker adoption among accounting staff. This is especially significant as the trend towards user-friendly applications continues to expand within the accounting profession.

  • Integration Capabilities: The ability to seamlessly integrate with existing accounting systems and other software tools is vital for efficient data management, allowing for a smoother workflow.

  • Automated Features: Software that includes automation for reminders, data entry, and report generation can significantly save time and reduce errors. Research indicates that an automated tracking system could save the accounting sector up to 1.7 million hours, underscoring the importance of these features. Glasscubes exemplifies this by providing automated reminders that enhance customer engagement and streamline information gathering, reducing response times by 50% and boosting interaction by 40%. Furthermore, Glasscubes offers a structured list feature that clearly outlines pending inquiries, ensuring efficient management of communications with customers.

  • Real-Time Reporting: Access to real-time information allows financial professionals to effectively track submissions and compliance status, enhancing decision-making and responsiveness. Glasscubes offers real-time insight into the status of customer requests, further assisting financial professionals in their compliance efforts.

  • Security and Compliance: Glasscubes is secure, encrypted, and GDPR compliant, promoting peace of mind for both firms and clients. This aspect is crucial in today’s data-sensitive environment. Dependable customer support is essential for diagnosing issues and maintaining seamless operations, particularly during busy tax periods, especially when evaluating making tax digital software options. By concentrating on these factors, accountants can choose MTD solutions that not only fulfil compliance standards but also improve overall efficiency. Successful implementations of making tax digital software options, as demonstrated in the case study ‘Long-Term Benefits of Making Tax Digital,’ have shown that businesses embracing digital processes can improve accuracy and efficiency, ultimately leading to better tax reporting outcomes. For instance, users like Sophie Montgomery from TaxAssist Accountants have reported significant time savings, with 288 hours saved in just one tax season, demonstrating the practical benefits of features like automation and real-time reporting.

Accountant Evaluating MTD Software

Comparative Analysis of Leading MTD Software: Features, Pros, and Cons

Glasscubes

  • Features: Comprehensive client portal, automated reminders, real-time reporting, unlimited client requests.
  • Pros: Glasscubes offers a user-friendly interface that has led to significant time savings for users. Companies report a remarkable 40% increase in customer response rates and a 50% reduction in response times. Customers appreciate the clarity of having all information centralised, which facilitates faster uploads and replies. The automated communication tools streamline the information collection process, enabling both accountants and customers to manage requests with greater efficiency.
  • Cons: Initial setup time may be required for full integration.

Xero

  • Features: Cloud-based accounting, invoicing, bank reconciliation, and MTD compliance.
  • Pros: Xero boasts strong integration capabilities with other financial tools and robust reporting features, making it a solid choice for diverse accounting needs.
  • Cons: Its higher cost compared to some competitors may deter smaller firms; additionally, its net promoter score (NPS) has dropped to +19, halving since 2021, indicating a decline in user satisfaction.

QuickBooks

  • Features: Comprehensive accounting features, MTD compliance, and mobile access.
  • Pros: As a well-established brand, QuickBooks provides extensive support resources and is easy to use for beginners.
  • Cons: Some users have reported issues with customer service responsiveness, and its starting price of $35 per month may be a barrier for some small businesses. QuickBooks is particularly suitable for solopreneurs and businesses such as retailers, construction firms, restaurants, and legal professionals.

This analysis underscores that while all three making tax digital software options provide essential MTD compliance features, Glasscubes stands out with its emphasis on customer engagement and operational efficiency, making it especially beneficial for busy accounting firms. The favourable feedback from users regarding streamlined communication and improved response times further cements its market position. Moreover, the rise of competitors like Bright Group illustrates a fragmented market where no single vendor dominates, yet competition remains vigorous. As Julian Green aptly noted, “Of those, Sage is expanding while Intuit QuickBooks and Xero usage is declining,” highlighting the evolving dynamics in the accounting tools landscape.

Choosing the Right MTD Software: Tailoring Solutions to Your Accounting Needs

Selecting the right making tax digital software options requires a thorough understanding of your firm’s unique needs and customer demographics. Consider these critical factors to guide your decision:

  1. Firm Size and Customer Volume: Larger firms typically require applications that accommodate multiple users and efficiently manage extensive customer data. Conversely, smaller firms may focus on cost-effective solutions that still offer essential functionalities. With the financial advisory sector reaching a market size of £6.5 billion in 2022 and growing at 7.2%, the choice of software becomes increasingly important.
  2. Type of Customers: The diversity of your customer base significantly influences programme selection. Firms catering to clients across various sectors may need solutions featuring advanced reporting capabilities and customisation options to meet specific industry demands. Notably, 49% of small business owners regard recommendations from other professional advisors as the most crucial resource when selecting an accountant, underscoring the importance of customer needs in software selection.
  3. Budget Constraints: It is essential to evaluate the total cost of ownership, which encompasses not only subscription fees but also training costs and potential integration expenses. Gaining insight into these financial aspects can empower firms to make informed choices that align with their budgetary constraints.
  4. Future Scalability: Opt for a solution that can evolve alongside your firm, accommodating increased client volumes and integrating new functionalities as your practise grows. This foresight can mitigate the need for frequent updates, which may disrupt operations. The global market for accounting applications is anticipated to reach $12 billion by 2026, highlighting the competitive landscape firms must navigate.
  5. User Training and Support: Assess the availability of training resources and customer support. A seamless transition to new applications is vital, and ongoing support can significantly enhance user experience and application utilisation. For example, users of Glasscubes reported substantial time savings, with one financial professional saving 288 hours during a tax season. Glasscubes’ automated reminder feature enables firms to send tailored reminders, ensuring that critical deadlines are met without the burden of lengthy email exchanges. This feature can be customised to send up to 10 reminders on a simple schedule or an unlimited number with advanced options, thereby improving client communication and operational efficiency.

By carefully evaluating these factors, accountants can select making tax digital software options that not only meet compliance requirements but also enhance overall operational efficiency, ultimately fostering improved client engagement and satisfaction.

Conclusion

The introduction of Making Tax Digital (MTD) is fundamentally reshaping the accounting landscape in the UK, compelling professionals to adapt rapidly to new compliance requirements. Accountants must embrace MTD-compliant software to streamline their operations and enhance client service. The selection of the right software hinges on key features such as:

  1. Compliance with HMRC regulations
  2. User-friendliness
  3. Integration capabilities
  4. Automation

This understanding is crucial as MTD not only represents a regulatory shift but also serves as an opportunity for accountants to improve accuracy and efficiency in their practices.

A comparative analysis of leading MTD software solutions highlights the strengths and weaknesses of each option. Glasscubes, with its focus on user engagement and operational efficiency, stands out as a particularly advantageous choice for busy accounting firms. Its automated features and real-time reporting capabilities can significantly reduce response times and enhance client interactions, making it a valuable tool for navigating the complexities of MTD compliance.

Ultimately, choosing the right MTD software is a strategic decision that can significantly impact an accounting firm’s success. By considering factors such as:

  1. Firm size
  2. Client demographics
  3. Budget constraints
  4. Scalability

Accountants can select solutions that not only meet compliance requirements but also drive operational improvements. As the digital transformation in accounting continues, those who proactively adapt and leverage technology will find themselves at the forefront of the industry, ready to deliver exceptional service and foster stronger client relationships.

About the Author:

Craig leads the Glasscubes Customer Success Department, with over 30 years experience in the field, helping accountancy firms achieve maximum success with collaborative technology.